6 replies to this topic

[Sunnah1]

He is anlaysis of what he said, wheither it was taken out of context or what not, he really shouldn't have used that as an example of taqleed, if you are going to dicuss the issue of taqleed dont attack those whom were already promised eternal heaven aswell having knowledge which was preserved for the later generations, through spending all those years learning off the prophet mohammed swt





Very good reponse, even thou it was taken out of context and i think he went a bit over emotional even thou i argee with him to some extint that comment was a very stupid comment to make

[shady_123]

First of all the " UK based african american ''so called graduate' you mentioned in the title is a respectable Scholar, so please respect him. In fact I have studied under him so this is an insult.

Quote

He is thinking of converting to rafidism?

Also what is the above about? Absolutely un-called for

The shaikh said nothing wrong, What he said in the full speech ( which was half quoted in the video) was no one but the prophet :[S.A.W.W]:should be followed blindly.

The [edited] Immam has poor adab, and is taking things too emotionally.

Quote

, if you are going to dicuss the issue of taqleed dont attack those whom were already promised eternal heaven aswell

Sh Abu Usamah wasn't attacking Abu Bakr . He was emphasising that even though Hz Abu Bakr was the best of this ummah after the prophet (saws) even then we cannot follow him blindly. Again watch the full video before commenting on bits and pieces.

To Mods - place in appropriate section. This shouldn't be in the sunni vs shia section

Edited by Jhangvi, 28 April 2011 - 04:23 PM.

[Jhangvi]

Quote

18. Any Member found in posting/replying Sectarian or inter-sectarian issues, will be warned 33% without any arguments and will be Banned for 100% on its third warning.

Attention:
Members are humbly requested to avoid any such discussion in public, that leads or tends to lead towards the above mentioned Forum Rule. By any means, Admins and Mods are very strict on this particular rule, so please be careful.

[junoon26]

brother jhangvi its a humble request.....why admin does not take an immediate action against such threads...admin should closed such threads in which there is minor chance of intermadhab debate can take place......if not to be closed at least should give a warning or advice that intermadhab debate cannot be not be tolerate......

[Sunnah1]

Quote

First of all the " UK based african american ''so called graduate' you mentioned in the title is a respectable Scholar, so please respect him. In fact I have studied under him so this is an insult.

You must do taqleed in him aswell? should we also say we shouldnt do taqleed in other sahaba

Quote

He is thinking of converting to rafidism?

Quote

Also what is the above about? Absolutely un-called for

The shaikh said nothing wrong, What he said in the full speech ( which was half quoted in the video) was no one but the prophet :[S.A.W.W]:should be followed blindly.

The deobandi Immam has poor adab, and is taking things too emotionally.

haha? what evidence do you have his [edited]? by any chance, hes hanafi if you wanted to know but i guess you are such a great student ''abu usamah'' youll defend until the end right

Nothing wrong? what attacking those whom want to fellow those whom  were promised jennah isn't wrong

Quote

Quote

, if you are going to dicuss the issue of taqleed dont attack those whom were already promised eternal heaven aswell

Sh Abu Usamah wasn't attacking Abu Bakr public/style_emoticons/default/17-RAAnhum.png. He was emphasising that even though Hz Abu Bakr public/style_emoticons/default/17-RAAnhum.png was the best of this ummah after the prophet (saws) even then we cannot follow him blindly. Again watch the full video before commenting on bits and pieces.

To Mods - place in appropriate section. This shouldn't be in the sunni vs shia section

Oh dear? we shouldnt fellow them? why not they were the best of generations, they were ones whom preserved the quran and were the ones that better than all of the scholars today and after, so your comment is [edited], i guess we shouldnt also follow the sahaba, many other prophets aswell

No what he said is [edited], and it must be exposed, i dont care if it is inter-sectarain he knew that what he said was going to cause an outrage he shouldnt kept his mouth quiet

Edited by Jhangvi, 28 April 2011 - 04:30 PM.

[Sunnah1]

I am going to end it here, but he said is [edited]!, i'd rather do taqleed in abu bakr than bin baz and ibn tamiiyah thats for sure

Edited by Jhangvi, 28 April 2011 - 04:31 PM.

[Jhangvi]

Admin's Note:

Members are humbly requested to avoid using harsh statements/words when discussing among selves please. As Muslims, we must adhere and follow the Sunnah of Sahabah   as mentioned in Quran:

Quote

Muhammad is the messenger of Allah, and those who are with him (The Sahabah), are hard against the disbelievers, compassionate among themselves....... [Surah Al-Fath, verse 29]

Topic closed!