5 replies to this topic

[Farid]

Alsalam alaykum,

I just thought that it would be beneficial to share this information from Tareekh Nisapur by Al-Hakim (p. 232):

Al-Hussain bin Dawud bin Ali bin Eisa bin Mohammed bin Al-Qassim bin Al-Hasan bin Zaid bin Al-Hasan bin Ali bin Abi Talib, according to Ibn Khuzaimah was the Imam of the Muslims in his time. He died in 355 AH.

Al-Hakim Al-Nisapuri, often seen as one of the more objective Sunnis (by Shias) due to his tashayyu states: He was the shaikh of the aal of the Prophet (pbuh) in his times in Khurasan, and he was one of the closest people emotionally to the companions of the Prophet (pbuh). I accompanied him for a period of time, and I prayed with him the Friday prayers for ten something years, and I never heard him say the name of Uthman without him saying, "Ameer Al-Mu'mineen," and he would cry. Nor would he mention A'isha without saying, "The sideeqa the daughter of al-sideeq the habeeba of the habeeb of the Prophet (pbuh)," and he would cry.

This was a scholar of ahlulbayt, since ahlulbayt include the children of Al-Hasan, and isn't restricted to fourteen individuals.

[saleh.neji]

Al-hakim (rah) was a sunni imam with special love for ahlbait(as) and this is how muslims should be.

[as300]

Assalam alaikoum

Brother Wasil,

All sunnies have special love for Ahl ul bait. Who wouldn't when we know they are the descendants of the Prophet saws?
But they do not restrict this definition to a bunch of people: they respect all of them.
What an extremist and restrictive definition shias are defending!

May Allah cure you brother

[Hani]

Salam `Aleykum,

Very useful information, but as I said brother Farid try to always provide Arabic texts :p

This is no surprise of course as it is well known that many from the earliest scholars of Ahlul-Bayt used to refute and disown the Rafidhah and those who become extreme in their Shiasm, and it is Mutawatir that Ahlul-Bayt at all times whether Hassani or Husseini praised the four Caliphs.

[saleh.neji]

as300, on 24 June 2012 - 10:45 AM, said:

Assalam alaikoum

Brother Wasil,

All sunnies have special love for Ahl ul bait. Who wouldn't when we know they are the descendants of the Prophet saws?
But they do not restrict this definition to a bunch of people: they respect all of them.
What an extremist and restrictive definition shias are defending!

May Allah cure you brother

jazakallah khairan akhi

shukran for the du'a

yes sunnis idolize ahlbait. you should go to morocco and see , wallah ahlbait (as) are loved by people to an amazing degree.

[Ebn Hussein]

Al-Hussain bin Dawud bin Ali bin Eisa bin Mohammed bin Al-Qassim bin Al-Hasan bin Zaid bin Al-Hasan bin Ali bin Abi Talib, according to Ibn Khuzaimah was the Imam of the Muslims in his time. He died in 355 AH.

This is Imam Al-Hakim? Wasn't Imam Hakim Zaydi?