maxxi

Hazrat Fatima [ra] ki shahadat ya wafat ?

176 posts in this topic

Shia hazrat kehtey hain k Haaazret Fatima r.a ko Hazret Umer r.a ne shaheed kia tha iss main kitni haqeeqet ha or kitna jhoot ha plz prove wid Refrences

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

pehle shion ko apna dawa sabit karna chahiye, usi ke baad hum jawab desakte hain dalail ke saat.. Aur doosri baat ye behuda jhoot hai..

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Asalaam Alaikum

Agar Aap Muslim hein tou aap ko Sahaba karaam kay kirdaar per zira barabar shak nahein hona chahiyae, Is board per ka-yee threads english mein hein jo Aap sawal ka jawab detein hein, Aap kay zhein koyee makhsoos waq=kaya hai to poochein, inshallah jawab danay key koshish karein gay. Aap is baat ko zaroor nazar mein rakhein kay yeh woh Sahaba hein jaab Uhad mein RasoolAllah[saw] key Jan ko khatra howa to sahaba karam nay apnay jism ko RasoolAllah[saw] ka dhaal bana lia, RasoolAllah[saw] kay dandanay mubarak Zakhmi howay Shahabi nay Apany kayee danat tor liaye. Aap english mein topic perhein inshallah aap ka shaq door ho ja aye ga.

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Mujhey sahaba per shek nhi mager mujh se aik shia ne sawal kia tha k or uss ne bohet se refrences diye main usko sawal ka jewab daina chaheta hoon

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Plz urdu main mujhey ans day dain i'll be very thankfull to you complete ans daina k unki wafat kaise howi mujhey uss shia ko jewab daina ha

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Bahee Wajah yeh hai kay meri Urdu key loghat bohat mahdood hai, is liaye aap nay dekha ho ga is board per bohat kum debate ho tee hai, aur mein shaad o nader he is main heessa layta hoon. Inshallah Koshish karoon ga, Agar koyee aur Bahee Urdu mein tahreer kar day to baihter hai.

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
<br />Asalaam Alaikum<br /><br />Agar Aap Muslim hein tou aap ko Sahaba karaam kay kirdaar per zira barabar shak nahein hona chahiyae,
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Shia hazrat kehtey hain k Haaazret Fatima r.a ko Hazret Umer r.a ne shaheed kia tha iss main kitni haqeeqet ha or kitna jhoot ha plz prove wid Refrences

Assalam-o-Alykum!

Aap ye segment daik lein; is jhooti tohmat se mutaliq sab sawalat ke jawabat mil jaein ge, inshAllah.

حقیقت ِاختلاف بین سیدہ فاطمہ و حضرت عمر

SEGMENT 8 - EPISODE # 158 - 168

http://islamic-forum.net/index.php?showtopic=12792

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

jab ye sab ho raha tha tu Ali(r.a) shere khuda kahan the shia kehte hen k unho ne saber ker lia tha Rasool(sw) ki naseehat thi... yar ab shia bhi saber ker len ali(r.a) ki sunat per amal ker len... ab ye unko q yad a reha hen.. Jab ali(r.a) ne Allah k superd ker dia tha tu shia bhi ker den.....ager shia kehte hen k sirf hazrat ali(r.a) ko naseehat ki thi.. tu yar us waqat jab ye waqia ho reha tha tu aik shia ko b gherat nahi aye koi tu apni gerdan katwa deta koi tu ler ker merta..akhir binte rasool(sw) pe zulm ho reha tha.. us waqat sab shia begherat ho gaye the ya ghar me chup ker bethey they... Allah tum(shio) ko is burai pe lanat kere.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Asalatu Aslamaulaika Ya Rasool Allah :RA Anha:

Wa Ala Alika Wa Ashabika Ya Habib Allah :biggrin:

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Shia hazrat kehtey hain k Haaazret Fatima r.a ko Hazret Umer r.a ne shaheed kia tha iss main kitni haqeeqet ha or kitna jhoot ha plz prove wid Refrences

Bhai jaisa k yahan per kuch members aap ko jhooti tasalian de rahay hain k yeh sab jhoot hai aisa koi waqiya hua hi nahi,iss k liye phir mein aap ko ahl sunnah ki books k scan pages dikhata hoon jis mein yeh waqiya mojood hai...

http://referencelibarary.webs.com/apps/photos/album?albumid=7125371

http://referencelibarary.webs.com/apps/photos/album?albumid=6826845

Aur ab mein aap ko woh pages dikhaon ga jis mein likha hai k hazrat abu bakar ne aakhri waqt mein kaha k kash mein Hazrat Fatima a.s k ghar ka darwaza tornay ki ijazat na deta khua woh jang k liye hi kun na bund kiya hota...

http://referencelibarary.webs.com/apps/photos/album?albumid=7912387

Yeh loag kitni books ko jhoota kahein ge ?? aur kon kon se riwayat ko ghalat kahein ge ??

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Shia hazrat kehtey hain k Haaazret Fatima r.a ko Hazret Umer r.a ne shaheed kia tha iss main kitni haqeeqet ha or kitna jhoot ha plz prove wid Refrences

Bhai jaisa k yahan per kuch members aap ko jhooti tasalian de rahay hain k yeh sab jhoot hai aisa koi waqiya hua hi nahi,iss k liye phir mein aap ko ahl sunnah ki books k scan pages dikhata hoon jis mein yeh waqiya mojood hai...

http://referenceliba...albumid=7125371

http://referenceliba...albumid=6826845

Aur ab mein aap ko woh pages dikhaon ga jis mein likha hai k hazrat abu bakar ne aakhri waqt mein kaha k kash mein Hazrat Fatima a.s k ghar ka darwaza tornay ki ijazat na deta khua woh jang k liye hi kun na bund kiya hota...

http://referenceliba...albumid=7912387

Yeh loag kitni books ko jhoota kahein ge ?? aur kon kon se riwayat ko ghalat kahein ge ??

I dont know k me is baat ka kia jawab don ab tu parhe likhe shia bhi is baat ko man gayen hen k ye waqia nahi huwa.. bcoz ye waqia hazrat alir.a ki shan k khilaf he balke shio ki bhi shan k khilaf he coz kisi aik shia ne bhi us waqat iski muzamat nahi ki....pata nahi tum log q nahi mantey.. khud socho k kia ye waqia ho sakta he.... kia madine k sab merd begherat ho chuke they naozbillah....please yar kuch hosh k nakhun loo q shere khuda ko badnam kerne per tule huwe ho...

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I dont know k me is baat ka kia jawab don ab tu parhe likhe shia bhi is baat ko man gayen hen k ye waqia nahi huwa.. bcoz ye waqia hazrat alir.a ki shan k khilaf he balke shio ki bhi shan k khilaf he coz kisi aik shia ne bhi us waqat iski muzamat nahi ki....pata nahi tum log q nahi mantey.. khud socho k kia ye waqia ho sakta he.... kia madine k sab merd begherat ho chuke they naozbillah....please yar kuch hosh k nakhun loo q shere khuda ko badnam kerne per tule huwe ho...

Dekho meray bhai iss baat ko aap bay-ghairati nahi keh saktay balkeh Islam ko bachanay k liye qurbani hai...Agar aap history perho aur abu sufiyan ka uss waqt kirdaar perho jab woh Mola Ali a.s k paas aaya aur kaha k loagon ne aik budhay ko tum per fazeelat de di aur aap khamosh hain agar aap hukam dein to mein madina ki gallion ko jawanon se bhar doon...

abu sufiyan Mola ali a.s ki mohabbat mein aisa nahi keh raha tha balkeh woh chahta tha k Mola ali a.s unn k khilaf uth kharay hon aur aik jang shuru ho jaye aur jab kamzor ho jaein sab to tab mein inn ko khatam ker k phir wohi aqeeda le aaon jo Islam se pehlay tha...Iss liye thora sukoon se sochein k agar Mola Ali a.s uss waqt muzahimat kertay to aik jang start honi thi jis ka nuqsan Islam ko hona tha...baray nuqsan se bachnay k liye Mola Ali a.s ne apna zaati nuqsan berdasht kiya aur khamoshi ikhtiar ki...Sher Khuda yeh nahi hota k woh bas her waqt talwar hi nikal ker khara ho jaye balkeh sher e Khuda wohi hota hai jo taqat honay k bawajood Islam ko bachanay ki khatir khamosh rahay zulm per....

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now