Forgot your password?
Or sign in with one of these services
Question: Some Sh
yeah the same would go for abu baker, when he was trying to break and burn down hz. fatima a.s house, prophet pbuh would have said the same and possibly worse about him
And wheres you hadith .... cited with full isnad.....is it sahih ?
Please show so we may discuss.
edited for none english response[/quote]Do not try to spoil the topic
Do not try to spoil the topic
Translate ur posts to english please and inshallah they wont be deleted.
Mod Note: use of any other language other than english on this board is ot allwed, you ar new to the board so I have just edited you whole post pls post in english.
FATIMA A,S SAID::::
MERE JANAZE PER IN DONO KO NA ANE DENA????????
WHY ABU BAKER NOMINATED OMER FOR NEXT KHALIFA???????????????
JAB K RASOOL ALLAH DID NOT NOMIATED ANY PERSON FOR KHILAFAT A/C TO YOU PEOPLE
A/C TO US RASOOL ALLAH NOMIATED ALI FOR KHILAFAT???????
Q#2 WHAY OMER SADI AGER FALAN HOTE TU MAIN UN KO KALIFA BANA DETA FALAN HOTY TU UN KO AB YE NAHI HAIN TO EK KAMETI BANADI? YE RIGHT UN KO KIS NE DIA
JAB K RASOOL ALLAH KI SUNAAT TU NAHI HAI YE A/C 2 U PEOPLE
Most of the question has been answered in your other thread please stick with it if you just one question.
As for your issue about Hz. Fatima[ra] asking not to let the "two" attend her funeral, is utterly nonsense, the lady who gave bath to the body of Hz. Fatima[ra] was the wife of Khallif[ra] and if she was there then definately khalif[ra] was there too. Read your own books. Not just listen to your ignorant zakirs.
as i have already relpied in some other post that the main source of the riwaits are Bihar ul Anwar( B.A).
and i have already given the scan of book of ayatullah Saeed Murtuza Askari named" Ahiya e deen mai ahl e bait ka kirdar" that the traditions about seerat of fatima zehra present in (B.A) is orignally taken from the books of Ahl e Sunnat and those are fabricated.
and as you alread know that no shia have ever claimed that there books have no fabricated traditions as Sunni claims.
P.S: The scan of book.
i was sending a post in another thread but mistakenly posted that here.
Can you please tell me,who killed Hazrat bibi Aisha?
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Already have an account? Sign in here.