Guest Jogi

Nabi [saww] ke janazay ko chorr ke chalay gaey Saqifa

452 posts in this topic

Allama Shibli Numani Ahle Sunnat ke Shamsul Ulema hain

wo kitab Al Farooq Page 40 per likhte hain

keh ye SACH hai keh Hazrat Abu Baker or Hazrat Umer dono Nabi(s) ke JANAZA be gor o kafan chor ker SAQIFA chaley gae

Scan Page

post-4338-1213519480_thumb.jpg

Edited by Umm Abdullah
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thora time nikal k is ka tafseeli jawab isi kitab AL-FAROOQ se parh liya hota to uchalnay ki zarurat nahi parti. Isi kitab ka typed-transcript version parh lo to shayad kuch aqal aa jaye.

http://www.kr-hcy.com/special/doubts/saqifa/index.shtml

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
bhai aap ne page sahi se attach nahi kiya shayed...khair mein woh page upload ker deta hoon ta k 123 k maananay walay bhi apni aankhon se perh lein.

post-4315-1213525638_thumb.jpg

ye kaheyn gey key ye page tempered hai.

{EDITED}

Edited by Umm Abdullah
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
ye kaheyn gey key ye page tempered hai.

aur mushrikon aao, aur dekho apney khulafa kaa tamaasha jo unhoney Rasool -asws kaa janaza bhee na dekha

6 safhaat ka ye mazmoon hai, zara pura parh layna phir agar kuch samajh aye to bolna. adha mazmoon attach kar k hamara keemti waqt barbad na karo.

aray jhangvi sahab agar sirf links hi denay hotay hain tum laogon ko to phir post hi kiun kertay ho...sirf links de diya karo her koi khud perh le ga...kiya hcy walon k ilawa aap k mazhab mein na koi aqal rakhta hai aur na hi ilm jo her waqt link de ker bhag jatay ho ?? bachay hum yahan sirf links denay k liye nahi bethay balkeh debate k liye ahin...link do lakin sirf ref. k liye tum loagon ko site link denay ya uss se copy paste kernay k ilawa kuch aata hi nahi hai...

Link is liye dia hai k pura mazmoon parho phir baat karna... Batein kam banaya karo, asli maqsad ki taraf aya karo.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 safhaat ka ye mazmoon hai, zara pura parh layna phir agar kuch samajh aye to bolna. adha mazmoon attach kar k hamara keemti waqt barbad na karo.

Link is liye dia hai k pura mazmoon parho phir baat karna... Batein kam banaya karo, asli maqsad ki taraf aya karo.

asli maqsad ye hai key rasool-allah ka janaza zada important thha yaa , maal ka batwara.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Thora time nikal k is ka tafseeli jawab isi kitab AL-FAROOQ se parh liya hota to uchalnay ki zarurat nahi parti. Isi kitab ka typed-transcript version parh lo to shayad kuch aqal aa jaye.

http://www.kr-hcy.com/special/doubts/saqifa/index.shtml

tu kuch zyada hee aqalmand hai

ye forum hai

yahan per Kitabon se DEBATE hotee hai na KEH LINKS diya jatey hain

{EDITED}

MOD NOTE: For non-topic stuff

Edited by Umm Abdullah
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

salam

most of them can only talk by reading the answers at kr-hcy.

wassalam

-1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Jhangwi Sahab Scan faqat aik page hee ka deeya jaata hai puri keetaab scan nahee kardi jaati zara ankhein kholein??

Agur Hum apne Daw'eh mai Jhoote hai to zara Dalail laien aap?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Shia qom ko ajeeb sa complex hai, bajaye is k k pura waqia parh k us per behes karay, aik safha utha k us ki aik line ko chun k us ka jawab mangtay hein. Lo Shio, pehlay is waqiye ko puri tarha parh lo, phir agay baat karna.

001.gif

002.gif

003.gif

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

jhangvi

kya aap is baat ko mantey hain keh

hazrat (abu baker,omar,usman) Nabi(s) ke janazay ko chor ker chaley gaey???

sirf is baat ka jawab do

ager debate nain kerni aatee tu kisi molvi ko lao

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
jhangvi

kya aap is baat ko mantey hain keh

hazrat (abu baker,omar,usman) Nabi(s) ke janazay ko chor ker chaley gaey???

sirf is baat ka jawab do

ager debate nain kerni aatee tu kisi molvi ko lao

Debate k liye mai akaila hi kafi hun tum logon k liye. Pehlay pura mazmoon parho phir baat karna, agar mazmoon parhnay ka hosla nahi hai to kisi hosla-mand ko lao jo tumhari tarha puray waqiye ko sayaq-o-sabaq se hat aik line ko parh kar hi ana ka masla na banaye. Waqiya pura parho, tumhein tumharay sawal ka aur hamaray dalail ka jawab bakhubi mil jaye ga.

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

jhangvi topic ka title perh

main ne ye nain poocha ke KYUN GAEY

sirf ye hai keh Nabi(s) ke janazay ko chor ker chaley gaey

tu accept kerta hai ya nain?

KYUN GAEY...ager ye discuss kerna hai tu naya TOPIC bana le

laiken is topic per ager himmat hai tu mere saboot ko JHUTLA

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

kaan idhar se pakaro ya udhar se, baat ghoom kar wahin ati hai. roti ko chochi kehna chour do ab!!!

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

salam

is liye k agar dair kartay tu khilafat hath sey chali jati

wassalam

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now